XR: Sortition, or Basic income?

Extinction Rebellion (XR) demands that we stop trashing the Planet, and sees ‘Sortition’ as an essential  tool. Brett Hennig’s TED talk makes many valid points. Yes, democracy is malfunctioning but that is in my opinion not due to faulty institutions, but because they are operating on out of date assumptions.

Sortition does not aim to replace democracy, but a new format – random selection of individuals who would govern – would overcome the failures by governments. But If those individuals still operate on unchanged assumptions, I do not see why a more constructive debate would emerge.

Sortition will not work unless there is a new mind set. The world is currently on a cusp. We are at the end of a long period when growth, in both population and per capital wealth, seemed natural aims. We are now at a point where we must treat the ecosphere as finite, and vulnerable.

I must repeat here what I have said many times, that there are two forces still preventing a very necessary change. One is the Tragedy of the Commons, whereby attempts to change from policies which take growth opportunities for granted will fail unless they are unanimous and enforceable – world wide, The other force is the hard-wired aversion to short term loss.

I have also repeated many times that I am still waiting for a better idea than the universal, unconditional basic (citizens’) income (UBI) as a component at least making this necessary mind set change possible. This aspect of a UBI is overlooked by those who pore over its more practical ramifications

But if this mind set change does happen, I see no reason why the existing governance structures, evolved over many centuries, would not work. At least we should see how they coped, in preference to an untried novelty. I do not necessarily dismiss the ancient Greek precedent, but surely it would make more sense to change as little as possible at this extremely unpredictable juncture which has created the need for XR, and Greta Thunberg’s school strike.

The admittedly dramatic result of the Citizens’ Assembly in Ireland is not, in my view as telling as appears at first sight. The necessary mind set change from the previous orthodoxy had already happened.

Unlike Sortition, the UBI does now have traction in the mainstream, but for very different reasons, some of which frighten me if it is not firmly tied to eco-concerns.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.